When you sign up to be a member of a political party you do so because you fundamentally believe in their ideology enough to want to put your money where your mouth is and make a difference. I did exactly that when i joined the Liberal Democrats from Labour a number of years ago.
I make no secret of the fact that I was highly suspicious of going into coalition with the Conservatives in May 2010 but I, like many others, was willing to go along with it if it meant making a real effort to clean up the mess that the Labour government of the last 13 years had left us in. I went along with it in the hope that the Liberal Democrats would temper some of the more rampant Conservative desires.
Today that faith in what my party has been trying to achieve has been rocked to its core for two reasons. Firstly the Welfare Reform Bill passed through parliament today without the amendments pressed for by the Liberal Democrats which would have seen vulnerable people protected from some of the more vicious cuts. The second is a more personal reason. I work for a charity that provides services to deaf people, people with a hearing loss and people with hearing loss and learning difficulties. Today my party in coalition not only failed them, it also failed me. Thanks to the devastating cuts to local services and cuts in funding from national government, my charity is at risk of not being able to provide services to people who need them the most. As a result, I was put on notice of redundancy today and my post no longer exists.
So what I hear you say. You make things look pretty and buy print. Yes I do, but it is part of a much larger picture. The literature that I help produce raises awareness of the issues people with hearing loss face. It attracts new members in our magazine and fundraising material. It attracts people who fundraise for us. It advertises services up and down the country that many people with a hearing loss could not do without. I am part of a well oiled machine that helps gets those services recognised.
Today, thanks to this government and my party’s part in it, I am looking at an uncertain future. I have no savings, no pension and no one to help me out of a hole that is gaping in front of me. I do not have credit cards to help me get by and it is just me myself and I. So what do I do now? Like millions of other people up and down the country I have to try to find something else. At this stage in my career it is not easy. My sector is always the first to get cut. In the last recession it took me 10 years to find a job that i had trained to do. I don’t have the luxury of doing that this time as I don’t live at home with my parents. I will probably have to take any job I can simply to keep a roof over my head.
Even that may be hard on a reduced salary. I am no in need enough to be a priority on council housing and I don’t qualify for benefits. Frankly the thought that I might even have to apply for benefits appalls me. I have never done so in my life and to do so would be like admitting failure. Benefits are for those in dire need, not people like me who can work. Why should I be forced into this position by a government that seemingly has no regard for people who’s circumstances are somewhat less than our own?
But what saddens me the most is the prospect of leaving an organisation that I would frankly lay down my life for. For the first time in my career I can see that my work has a positive impact for people who need help. I can see that what I am doing is worthwhile and not just some part of a corporate machine designed to make money for corporate shareholders. I feel as though I am having to leave behind the people I have been helping over the past three years and it kills me.
When I signed up to be a Liberal Democrat I did so because we were the party of fairness. The party that made sure that no one gets left behind. I see none of that in either of the two circumstances that have happened today. All I see is a trail of despair that is opening up for those that need help. I’m not being dramatic. I am seeing it with my own eyes. Does this government or the Liberal Democrats understand or care what happens to a person when their hearing is gone. Do they understand the isolation that a person feels when they cannot hear the things we take for granted? The person in the shop when you buy something, the conversations with grand children, the help with services that you are trying to access? On today’s evidence I would say they don’t. What is even worse is that for the first time I would say that both of them do not care.
This is not why I joined this party. I lost two things dear to me today. My job and my faith in my party and what it is trying to do. The first may be easier to get back though not in the kind of organisation I would want to be. The second may be something I never get back. I am ashamed to be a member of this party and this government tonight and don’t know how we will ever be able to look the electorate in the eye with a straight face again.

John Reynolds says:
Ok – so firstly you work for a charity, so if they are making redundancies it is their choice, not sure how you can blame the government for this. Also a charity making a designer redundant is hardly impacting on the work they do is it now?
Secondly even if it is the governments fault – you as a vocal libdem supporter for a number of years have supported them and this coalition while billions worth of cuts were made, putting thousands out of work. Yet this you were happy to support all the time it didn’t affect you personally. Now it does you stand condemning the same policies.
I am sorry but this makes you a hypocrite
Spidey says:
And your comments make you look rather ridiculous I am afraid. If You have been a regular reader of this blog you will see that I am not a follower of this coalition and have been one of its harshest critics. I have long condemned this governments stance on the welfare reform bill but i suspect you are simply trolling looking for a reaction
Anyway, you also fail to see the direct impact that my work has. I am not a designer. I do many different things for the charity including campaigning and working with the services that we provide to those that need it. The cuts my charity have made are as a direct result of the cuts that government has made and the resulting effects it is having on our ability to offer services to those that need them.
I also think it worth pointing out that i have worked hard in my community to protest about the cuts but then again you tarnish all LibDems with the same brush and wouldn’t know about that either.
John Reynolds says:
You may have protested about some of the measures, but your reaction now is to “lose faith in the party forever”. Something which none of the other measures have caused you to do. As I said you seem to be reacting most strongly when it affects you personally.
Please also note that I haven’t “tarnished (tarred?) all libdems with the same brush” I have only mentioned one – you.
If you have lost faith forever why not post a pic of you tearing up your membership card, or are you just venting?
Spidey says:
As I have already said to you, I have done far more than simply protest occasionally. There is a reason some LibDems refer to me as a pariah. It’s because if I dont like something I say and will not toe the line simply to please the party.
If things don’t change and soon, I’ll walk. And I’m big enough to be a person of ‘y word but again, you don’t know me so you wouldn’t know that.
John Reynolds says:
Ok fair enough, what needs to change and in what time limit before you walk?
Spidey says:
This government needs to reverse the destructive policy of the welfare reform bill and the destruction and privatisation of the NHS.
I stood as a candidate last year for this party. I can’t look voters in the face right now. It disgusts me. I don’t think I can do that again
John Reynolds says:
To be honest from the way you are talking you should quit libdems, if you’ve lost faith in them and you can face the voters under their banner then I don’t see any point in continuing to be a member.
They won’t and can’t reverse either welfare or NHS reform.
Spidey says:
Perhaps that’s why I’ve just got my bank to cancel my direct debit. I won’t be renewing it
Tim says:
Sorry about the redundancy, Lisa, I hope you find something good soon. As a Deafie, I know that you would do a cracking job for any organisation that helps Deaf people – if they really believe in what they do, they would head-hunt you!
BTW I think John’s response just proves right what you say about the government neither knowing nor caring about the effects of todays events on Deaf people.
Spidey says:
Exactly that Tim. Frankly this govt simply doesn’t seem to care about the impact that it is having on the lives of deaf people. Frankly it breaks my heart. And thanks for the words of support x
John Reynolds says:
Oh – In what way does my comment prove anything about the governments attitude to deaf people?
Richard Dawson says:
As a hard of hearing person I really understand the sentiment Lisa but you never been a staunch supporter of the Coalition have you and naturally when it affects you feel sore I guess I would .
But looking at the bigger picture this is a case of the difference between being in opposition and government hard choices when faced with a deficit inherited from Labour.
I think thats the thing that concerns me about so many Lib Dem members they behave like they are still in opposition we need to behave like we are in Government and own its successes and failures .
Stay and fight your’re an asset to the party and would be a sad loss
Spidey says:
It’s got nothing to do with behaving like I’m in opposition. It’s about known g that what we are doing is wrong and people who need our help are suffering. No amount of power is worth that
Richard Dawson says:
Like I say the freedom of opposition versus the hard choices of government its a tough world out there
Neil says:
Spidey, sorry to hear about the impending redundancy I wish you all the best in finding something new and hopefully better.
Richard/John, I’m not a party member just a repeat voter for the LDs. And I’m struggling to why I should do so again. What happened today wasn’t a ‘hard choices in government’ moment it was a capitulation at the expense of some of the most vulnerable people in the country. There is money when it’s wanted – £40 000 000 for fireworks a few weeks ago, the IFS popped up today to say there is scope for £10 000 000 000 for tax cuts as stimulus, the BoE is debating how many tens of billions to magic up in QE this month…. And the LDs can’t even sustain an amendment supported by a Tory rebellion in the HoL saying you shouldn’t have to pay an upfront fee to chase child support.
I dread reading the paper tomorrow to find some woeful ‘whataboutery’ directed at Labour that tries to justify why none of the amendments could be supported.
Geoffrey Payne says:
It is not actually the party that has let you down. We supported the motion by George Potter at the last conference opposing the benefit cuts, specifically in relation to disabled people but the principle holds true across the board.
The problem is that there is a small clique that runs the leadership of the party that is forcing the party in a particular direction it does not want to go. Those of us who do not agree need to resist this as much as we can. If we leave then by default we hand over power by default to those we disagree with.
Valerie T says:
The problem is, Geoffrey, that we didn’t make enough fuss about this to stop it, and now it’s too late. Yes, there was the conference motion which was great, and then there was the letter signed by 57 candidates etc. which was also great, but too many members have just been silent on this issue, pretending it wasn’t happening, looking the other way, and just wildly promoting the good news (e.g. on our tax proposals).
I’ve been a staunch defender of the coalition (and the leadership) on other issues, but I’m seething about the votes last night – really, really angry.
David Grace says:
Very sorry to hear your news, Lisa. I can’t help thinking it’s the government that’s deaf.
I was defending the party against an old friend’s attacks on Monday night. People, especially people who have never done anything to get anyone elected or delivered a leaflet or knocked on a door or taken any useful action to change anything, make no distinction between ministers in government and party activists. I disagree with much the Liberal Democrats in government have done but I know that no other party comes near my ideals. I have been a Liberal for 37 years, joining from Labour like you. Nothing the current party leadership has done will stop me being a Liberal and despite everything, the Liberal Democrats remain the party which is nearest my ideals. For me there is no alternative party worth joining so the only alternative would be to give up party politics altogether which would also mean giving up even the little influence I have now. It would be easy to become one of the non-activists critics of politics but I choose to keep fighting to make the party better. I don’t see you as becoming an armchair critic so I hope you will also choose to stay in the end. In a few years the coalition will be over and we will still need a Liberal party then.
Dave says:
I agree with Geoffrey Payne, and have long since decided that I won’t vote in the next election. I intend to let Clegg’s Lib Dems die out and then return after his resignation.
Don’t think this is a problem with the Lib Dems – there are plenty of Labour and Tory supporters at the moment that have similar issues with their party leadership. Labour are still in denial regarding the method we got into this financial mess, and many old Tory boys thought Cameron was a hero when he ended talks on the European bailout, only to think him a sellout when he returned and played ball. This is an issue with political parties in general – they’re not something you can have “faith” in, because by nature they behave in the manner the leaders require.
I would also like to point out that Nick Clegg hasn’t changed a bit – he has always had some right-leaning views. We empowered him, now he’s merely doing the kind of things he told us he would. That’s our fault, not his.
Spidey says:
One of the main reasons I never voted for Nick Clegg as leader Dave. I didnt trust him.
John Reynolds says:
From reading a lot of comments here I would say your views are better represented by the liberal party (not lib-dems, I mean the rump of the old liberal party pre merger)
Spidey says:
it would seem so. Told you I was the pariah
Pingback/Trackback
Top of the Blogs: The Lib Dem Golden Dozen #259
Chris Gilbert says:
Hi Spidey,
I went through a similar situation last October when the company I work for who make social care software made around 20% of the staff redundant. It’s a small company, but the impact of reduced government spending had an immediate impact on what we could charge local authorities, so we had a position where we had to cut jobs or go out of business.
I managed to keep my job by negotiating part time hours, and I am now working more hours again, and happy I was able to stay. However, it was a really tough time for me, happening a week after closing a sale on my house, and I didn’t know how I’d cope.
My advice to you – keep your self esteem up as much as you can, and start trying job interviews as soon as possible. Don’t put too much pressure on yourself – it’s not your fault what happened.
As a now ex lib dem member myself I know how you feel. I’d only just joined and campaigned before the election, to see a reversal of many of the principles I felt they represented.
And politics isn’t about making ‘tough decisions in government’, it’s about making the right decisions in government. Whether they are ‘tough’ or not is all about posturing. Looking like you are tough on ‘Labour’s deficit’ is only something that bond markets care about, not voters.
Spending money on your credit card to get to work and back, is not a waste of money. Which is pretty much how I feel about the coalition’s policies. Not everything is a waste of money. It is more wasteful to allow services which have taken many years to build disappear for the sake of saving a pittance.
Apparently it’s possible to simultaneously argue we are spending too much on services though, and still argue the queen needs a new yacht.
Locally, our borough council has tried to shut polling stations, at the incredible saving of £100 for room hire. Now that’s cost saving the Conservatives can be proud of.
Saving money is all well and good if it doesn’t cost you anything. Sadly, most of the cuts the government is making will cost us dearly.
There’s no economy in the history of the world that has magically grown through less government spending. We are supporting people who have literally no experience in economics, not even having had jobs outside of the conservative party (and I speak of our venerable chancellor here.) Why on earth would you trust an unqualified account to do your books, let alone the entire country’s budget?
I’d rather have loyalty to my principles than an arbitrary club. Lots of people in politics ought to learn for themselves as much as you seem to be able to do.
So good luck for the future, and keep up the good fight, whatever arbitrary club you choose to associate yourself with
thanks,
Chris
Spidey says:
Thanks for the comments Chris. I think it is fair to say that i agree with you in more ways than you can imagine.
Im just so disappointed in the whole thing that I dont know where to start right now.
What I am going to do is just keep to my local activism stuff and make a difference where I know it counts. For local residents. I want to do that as best as i can.
Lx
Kel says:
Hey Spidey,
Genuinely upset to read this post. Am so sorry about your at-risk status, and if I (in my ex-union rep capacity as well as a friend and fellow charity worker) can help at all, please let me know
Kel
Spidey says:
Thanks hon. I really appreciate that! Will let you know how i get on. Lx
Gareth Loveridge says:
Hi Spidey,
I haven’t commented before but I would just like to say I really enjoy reading your blog.
I totally understand how you feel at the moment with regards to some of the shameful proposals within the Welfare Reform Bill which have made me feel very, very uncomfortable and very concerned with what we are doing as a party and it has led to me also questioning whether I want to stay a member of a party that appears happy to trample over the sick and most vulnerable in society.
I, like you also used to be a Labour supporter before switching my support to the Lib Dems prior to the last General Election so I was also somewhat uncomfortable with going into coalition with the Tories so you are not alone with your concerns.
Anyway, what I’m trying to say is don’t quit the party as voices like yours and mine are needed more than ever and the moment and will be needed once the coalition is over in a few years so please don’t give up as despite how tough and uncomfortable things are and I appreciate they are very tough and very uncomfortable at the moment, we need to stay and fight or we basically let the Tories and Labour have a free hand and we certainly do not want or need that.
Whatever you decide to do, I would like to wish you luck for the future and say keep your head up and keep the faith.
Gareth
Spidey says:
Hi Gareth
Thanks for taking the time to reply and make such lovely comments. Its always nice when people who read but don’t comment feel compelled to come and say something so I really appreciate it.
My membership is not in question right now having calmed down. My loyalty to the coalition is however and it wont come back. Its one of the reasons that this week I have joined ‘Liberal Left’. I believe that their voice is going to be heard more and more over the coming months and they will be fundamental in bringing the party back to its homestead.
Many thanks again and keep up the good fight
Spidey
Pingback/Trackback
How the Liberal Democrats suspended me for having an opinion